Have you recently come to the conclusion that your business needs a fractional CMO (fCMO)? If you’ve read our “7 signs it’s time to hire a fractional CMO ” article and realised that some or the majority of those signs apply to your own business scenario, then you might be wondering where to start when looking for the right partner.
Choosing the right fCMO can deliver on-demand marketing leadership, transform your marketing strategy, and drive measurable impact across your organisation, but it’s vital to make the right choice. Working with an fCMO that ends up being the wrong fit can waste time, budget, and momentum for your marketing activities.
This article will walk you through key things to consider before hiring, what to expect from an fCMO, and how to identify the agency that will become a trusted partner for your marketing needs.
Getting started: what you should consider
Before you begin your quest for a fractional CMO, you should arm yourself with a list of what you need and note down any limitations or restrictions you might have. The clearer you are about what you’re looking for and what you have to offer in return will make your search easier. Consider the following points for your list:
- Budget
Define your budget for marketing. This includes not just the fCMO’s fee, but a realistic operational budget for them to work with and get the results you’re looking for. And remember that while an fCMO will be more cost-effective than a full time CMO, they will still be an executive-level expert and will expect to be paid accordingly for the time they invest in your business.
- Timelines
Before you start your search, you’ll first need to define the problem or challenge you want the fCMO to solve. If it’s a challenge of a temporary nature, such as a big project or temporary situation you need support with, then you may only need an fCMO for a few months. If your challenge is more growth- or change-related, then you will likely require a strategic partnership that lasts longer.
- Goals
It’s helpful to be clear about what you want to accomplish with your new fCMO. Do you want to improve lead generation or make your marketing spend more efficient? How will your marketing goals help you achieve your overall business objectives? Clarifying your goals will help you understand the type of expertise you’ll need in an fCMO.
- Team
An fCMO will provide you with marketing strategy and leadership, but they won’t be executing marketing campaigns by themselves. You’ll need to have a strong team to implement your fCMO’s vision; some of these may be internal resources and others may need to be outsourced for specific expertise areas.
What a fractional CMO can offer
As you probably already know, a fractional CMO is a senior marketing leader who joins your business on a part time or project basis to provide strategic marketing direction without the cost of hiring a full time CMO. The fCMO becomes an integrated part of your leadership team, making sure that your marketing activities are aligned with your business objectives and that every decision is backed by data and expert insight.
Advantages they bring to the table include cost-efficiency, integration with your team and flexible support that can scale with your growth. They can oversee all aspects of your marketing activities, including strategic planning, brand development, digital marketing, SEO and mentoring your internal marketing team.
If you’d like to know more about the advantages fCMOs can offer your business, it’s worth revisiting our “Benefits of a fractional CMO” post to see all the details.
Finding the right agency fit
Every business is different, and so is every fractional CMO agency. The key to finding the right partner is making sure your goals are clear and that the agency’s values are closely aligned with yours. Make sure to check the following points to ensure a great relationship that you’ll be happy with:
- Industry expertise
Look for an agency that understands your industry and customer base. For example, a business-to-business company probably won’t fit well with an agency that’s more experienced with consumer businesses. And an fCMO with a relevant sector-specific background will be able to hit the ground running and deliver impact faster than someone who has to learn about the industry from scratch.
- Business size
An fCMO agency specialised in working with startups and SMEs may not be the right choice for a larger, more established enterprise, and vice versa.
- Geographical needs
Do you need someone in the office for in-person leadership or does the majority of your team work remotely? If you have a remote working culture, that widens your search criteria, but if you need someone in the office, you’ll need to look for an agency that has marketing experts based in your region.
- Leadership style
As your fCMO will be working with your board, heading up your marketing team and ensuring cross-functional collaboration with other teams, it’s important to make sure their leadership style aligns with your organisational culture and values.
- Business track record
It almost goes without saying that you need to look for a fractional CMO agency that has a proven track record. They should have been in existence for a good amount of time and have a wide range of recent testimonials and case studies to access.
- Capacity
Although track record is important, having been in business for any length of time does not mean that an agency can deliver what you need when you need it. Make sure that the agency you select has capacity and capability to deliver, without compromises. At The Marketing Centre, for instance, we have a team of 100+ fCMOs nationwide covering a wide range of sectors and specialisms. That breadth gives you a far greater chance of finding your ideal fCMO fit.
Questions to ask when choosing a fractional CMO to partner with
Before you sign on the dotted line, make sure you take some time to interview your shortlisted agencies and ask the right questions to avoid making the wrong choice. A dependable partner will welcome your questions.
Here are some key points to push for when formulating your questions:
|
What results have you delivered for similar companies? |
Look for case studies – not anecdotes – with relevant companies in the same or similar sectors. Ensure they provide measurable outcomes. |
|
What can we expect in the first 90 days? |
This will reveal how they will approach strategy and planning in the early days of the agreement. |
|
What do you not do? |
Good agencies will be honest about their strengths and limitations. |
|
How do you measure and report success? |
Look for examples of clear KPIs, dashboards and how the agency communicates with clients. |
|
What do you need from us to succeed? |
Strong partnerships rely on shared responsibility, so the agency should be upfront about what you need to implement internally to get the best results from a fractional CMO arrangement. |
|
What frameworks or methodologies do you use? |
This will help you understand if they have a structured way of working that conforms with marketing best practices. |
|
What leadership approach does your proposed fCMO take? |
Make sure your proposed fCMO will be a good cultural fit with your team and the way they are used to working. |
|
How do you handle data and security? |
NDAs and data protection policies should be standard practice. |
|
Can you provide proof of past successes? |
Look for recent, credible testimonials and case studies that include metrics, not just generic praise. Ask if there are video testimonials that will enable you to hear the results in the client’s own words, or ask if you can have a more informal chat with a happy client to get their opinion. |
Red flags to look for when choosing a fractional CMO
As we mentioned before, not all agencies or fractional CMOs are equal. The term “fractional CMO” has become a popular trend that some organisations and individuals have tried to leverage without the senior-level experience and proven track record it should be backed up with.
Watch out for:
- Promising unrealistic things e.g. “We’ll double your revenue in 60 days”
- Vague testimonials without quantifiable metrics
- Unusually low pricing or discounts
- Lack of responsiveness or poor communication early on
- No relevant industry experience
- Not being willing to adapt to your needs
- Avoiding interviews or reference checks
These are all signs of an agency or individual that might not be able to deliver the strategic leadership your business requires.
While it can be tempting to look for an independent fCMO yourself, partnering with a reputable fractional CMO agency gives you a far greater chance of success, as the track record and experience level of each fCMO will have been thoroughly vetted by the agency. They’ll also have a wide range of experts to choose from, so you can be confident you’ll be matched with someone who understands your sector, your challenges, and your growth ambitions from day one.
A good agency also provides structure and accountability. Your fCMO will be used to working in a more standardised way, with agreed frameworks and tools, a standard method of tracking progress, and the flexibility to adjust your support level as your needs evolve.
The combination of breadth, quality assurance, and continuity makes an agency partnership a safer, more scalable, and ultimately more effective route than hiring one individual independently or a small team that doesn’t have enough capacity to deliver.
The smart way to choose
As a fractional CMO agency, we know the selection process isn’t just about presenting credentials, it’s about earning trust. Don’t find yourself stuck with a fly-by-night business or underqualified individual that ends up wasting your time and money. As the client, you should take the time to understand your goals, ask the right questions, and go with the partner that ticks all the right boxes.
At The Marketing Centre, our network of 100+ proven marketing leaders covers every industry and region across the UK. We’re confident we can match you up with the right expert for your growth goals: someone who brings the right strategic insights, leadership, and measurable impact your business deserves.
Are you ready to find your perfect match?
